About Us

Lake Shore Insurance Agency is independently owned and locally operated to handle your insurance needs. We focus on Cleveland and offer affordable and reliable insurance choices all across Ohio.

We will help you find the right combination of tailored, personalized insurance coverage at just the right price to fit your needs.

Insurance Tailored For You

We invite you to complete an online quote, call us at 440-446-1600, or contact us at bill@lakeshoreinsurance.com to review coverage options for auto insurance, home insurance, life insurance, health insurance, business insurance, commercial insurance, renters insurance, boat insurance, and more. We provide free, no hassle and no obligation insurance quotes to help you make an informed insurance decision.

Affordable, Reliable Insurance Choices

Lake Shore Insurance Agency strives to offer you quality insurance coverage, a high level of professional service and a long-term relationship. As independent agents, we’ll research rates and coverage from top insurance companies to find the best insurance rates and insurance plans for you. We do the insurance shopping and comparing for you to save you time and money!

Call for a quote today at 440-446-1600.

Agency is licensed in the following states: Ohio

Press Release, April 2017

Principal Bill Rodgers announced the purchase of the Cashin & Smiley Insurance Group in Strongsville, Ohio. This is our first entry into the Westside of Cleveland and our 9th office. Steven Smiley and Wayne Cashin will be staying on to help us build the volume in this =new geographic marketing area. We look to purchase more Westside locations in the futureā€¦ Cashin & Smiley will expand from 3 carriers in their office to 16 carriers currently represented by Lake Shore Insurance although their primary focus will be to continue to develop and grow their primary carrier Erie Insurance Co.

Lake Shore continues to track at a fast pace purchasing independent insurance agencies in Northeast Ohio and looks to expand outside the State of Ohio in 2017 and 2018. The new offices will fall under the supervision of third generation owners and Bill Rodgers two daughters Nicole Rodgers Stewart and Kelsey Rodgers.

Get a Quote or call for a quote at 440-446-1600